Brighton's Newest Restaurant Is Named for a Parcel Churchill's Great-Grandfather Once Owned

Gray-blue clapboard home with red-brown brick foundation, white front door and damp concrete path beneath autumn maple branches.

At the corner of Elmwood Avenue and Johnsarbor Drive, a Town of Brighton historical marker says Winston Churchill's great-grandfather, Ambrose Hall, lived in Brighton from 1817 to 1821 and owned 210 acres in "lot #54."

Just down Elmwood, a restaurant opened this month using that lot number as its name. Lot54 Casual Kitchen sits in Village Square at Brickstone, 1325 Elmwood Avenue. It says its name comes from "the historic parcel of land on which it stands." Over two centuries, this stretch of Elmwood has been an early settler's 210 acres, a cemetery superintendent's holding, a horse farm and a senior living campus. Through all of it, the parcel number stayed the same. Now it's on a menu.

Who Has Held Lot 54

The lot is older than the Town of Brighton. The restaurant's About page calls Lot 54 "one of the original land parcels established following the Buffalo Creek Treaty of 1788." A history of early Brighton on the Meadowbrook neighborhood's site lays out the order of events. The Hartford Treaty of 1786 gave Massachusetts the right to sell western New York land and gave New York the right to govern it. The Phelps and Gorham Purchase and the Buffalo Creek Treaty followed in 1788.

An 1895 history of Monroe County says Brighton was mostly Township 13, Range 7 of that purchase. It lists the township's original buyers as General Hyde, Prosper Polley, Enos Stone, Col. Job Gilbert and Joseph Chapline, and says only Enos Stone is believed to have made Brighton his permanent home. The same account says Brighton was split off from the town of Smallwood on March 25, 1814. Smallwood's other half became Pittsford.

After that, the Town's marker names three owners of the lot:

  1. Ambrose Hall, Winston Churchill's great-grandfather, who owned 210 acres in Lot 54 from 1817 to 1821.
  2. George Stillson, the first superintendent of Mount Hope Cemetery.
  3. William and Janet Maxion, who ran a horse farm there from 1940 to 1982.

The horse farm is the link to what stands there now. St. John's describes its St. John's Meadows campus at 1 Johnsarbor Drive West as built "on the former site of Maxion Farms." Brickstone, home to Village Square and the new restaurant, is next to St. John's Meadows on Elmwood Avenue. The marker stands at the Johnsarbor corner, not at the restaurant's door. The restaurant's history rests on its own claim and on the Town's marker a short walk away.

A Retail Space Built for This

Brickstone opened on April 30, 2014, with 102 dwelling units and space for retail. The first restaurant in that space was Joey B's at Brickstone, which St. John's welcomed with a grand opening in 2015. Lot54 now fills what RochesterFirst called "the former home of Joey B's at Brickstone."

So the room was always meant for a restaurant. What's new is a team that built its whole identity around the land. The site's tagline reads "Built on historic ground. Crafted by local legends." One dinner entrée is called Brickstone Chicken.

The Two People Running It

RochesterFirst reported that Lot54 Casual Kitchen opened the week of October 2, 2026. The kitchen belongs to Brandon Wiggins, who created Amazing Grains Bakery in Fairport and sold it a few years ago after a decade of growing it. In that story he said the bakery "supplied over 100 restaurants with bread on the table every day." His well-loved salty bread from Amazing Grains shows up often on the new menu.

David Watkins runs the front of the house as general manager. His past work includes running Hicks and McCarthy in Pittsford. RochesterFirst reported that Watkins called Wiggins last year and that both saw Brighton needed a sit-down restaurant. In the same piece, Watkins described the gap like this:

"We asked, 'What is this area missing?' There used to be Zeb's and other things you could get out here. I don't want to say the phrase 'fine dining,' because I think that gets thrown around too much. It's going to be an elevated experience for dinner."

The restaurant he mentioned was Zebb's Deluxe Grill & Bar at Tops Brighton Plaza, known for its burger toppings bar, homemade milkshakes and warm chocolate-chunk cookies. The Democrat and Chronicle reported in February 2018 that the Brighton location had closed. That means Lot54 is pitching itself to a town that has gone more than eight years without Zebb's.

Wiggins told RochesterFirst he draws on time spent in South Carolina and Alabama, describing the food as "regional American cuisine with a lot of Southern influence."

What's on the Table, and When

According to RochesterFirst, Lot54 opened with dinner Wednesday through Saturday, with breakfast and lunch set to start October 13. The hours on the restaurant's contact page now include both:

Day Breakfast and lunch Dinner
Tuesday 7:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. Closed
Wednesday 7:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. 4 to 9 p.m.
Thursday 7:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. 4 to 9 p.m.
Friday 7:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. 4 to 9 p.m.
Saturday 7:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. 4 to 9 p.m.

Sunday and Monday aren't listed. The homepage mentions weekend brunch, and RochesterFirst said the team plans to add Sunday brunch later this fall. Check the posted hours before planning a Sunday visit.

The bread shows up throughout the day. The breakfast and lunch menu includes Cronut French Toast, a Sourdough Hootenanny, Shrimp & Grits and Steak, Eggs & Frites. At lunch there's the Harvest Sando, the Frybird and a McQ Burger served on a grilled salty-bread bun. An All Day Egg Sammy also comes on salty bread. Dinner includes Duck Confit Poutine, Spanish Mussels, Veal Schnitzel, Steak Frites and the Brickstone Chicken. The restaurant's menu page says dishes change with the seasons. The restaurant also takes reservations through its site, offers full-service catering, and has a separate events email for private bookings.

Brighton's Food Map Is Shifting Around It

Lot54 isn't the only change in Brighton this fall. One of the town's longtime bakeries is planning its own move.

In August, 13WHAM reported that Anna and Naf Hanau had closed on a property on South Winton Road. They plan to move Malek's Bakery there from its Monroe Avenue spot near Twelve Corners. Their company, Flower City Foods, took ownership of Malek's Bakery and Lipman's Kosher Market on January 1, 2025. Naf told the station the goal is a kosher market called Flower City Foods with bakery, deli and butcher, "all the things under one roof," targeted for 2027. Anna noted that the new space will have windows "in the store and in the kitchen." Until then, the bakery stays on Monroe Avenue.

Farther up Monroe Avenue, News10NBC reported on October 5 that the Starbucks on Monroe Avenue in Brighton is set to close. It's part of a company-wide restructuring of about 250 stores that also includes the South Main Street location in Fairport.

Taken together, these changes all point the same way. Owners already working in Rochester's food scene are betting on bigger, all-day formats in Brighton. Wiggins and Watkins are running a restaurant that serves breakfast, lunch and dinner. The Hanaus are combining a bakery and a butcher shop under one roof. And Lot54 has put a 1788 parcel number on the sign.

Know a corner of Brighton with a story like Lot 54's? We'd love to hear it. And if you want help finding the history behind your own street, or would like a list of places worth trying on the east side of town, Amy Petrone and our team are happy to talk Brighton any time. Reach out and Work With Us.

Work With Us

When you hire us you get all the services and advantages of a big team plus the one-on-one customer service of a boutique firm. We take pride in our client relationships and our accessibility!